String Intonation : Personal Expression and Pedagogical Challenges
Author
Summary, in English
In string performance of Western classical music, melodic intonation has generally been considered an expressive tool. However, empirical studies investigating performance intonation have often related intonation to different tuning systems, leaving music-contextual aspects of performance intonation rather unexplored. This work aimed to understand string musicians’ perceptual intonation preferences and their performance intonation, and how such expert knowledge is pedagogically transferred to future generations of string players.
This doctoral dissertation comprises four original publications: (1) a quantitative study on higher-education music students’ perceptual preferences regarding melodic intonation, (2) a mixed-methods study about concertmasters’ (highly skilled violinists’) intonation preferences in perception and in performance, (3) a survey study of string teachers’ experiences in teaching intonation at elementary and pre-college levels, and (4) a text study focusing on prominent string musicians’ verbal communication surrounding expressive intonation in performance. Hence, each of the studies investigates a different aspect of the main aim.
The findings of the first study suggest an expertise-related connection between violinists’ intonation preference and meter. The results in the second study indicate that concertmasters’ average leading-tone intonation was sharper than in both equal tempered and just intonations, in performance as well as in their perceptual preferences. In the third study, practising string teachers showed a rich variety of creative teaching strategies to make intonation apprehensible and accessible to children. The fourth study demonstrated how string pedagogues seemed to struggle with their verbal communication regarding intonation practice in expressive performance.
By shedding light on the application of expressive intonation in successful string musicians’ performance, this work discloses parts of musicians’ implicit knowledge concerning their contextually based intonation practice. These new insights may have implications for teaching intonation, inspiring to more efficient communication surrounding expressive performance in instrumental music education.
This doctoral dissertation comprises four original publications: (1) a quantitative study on higher-education music students’ perceptual preferences regarding melodic intonation, (2) a mixed-methods study about concertmasters’ (highly skilled violinists’) intonation preferences in perception and in performance, (3) a survey study of string teachers’ experiences in teaching intonation at elementary and pre-college levels, and (4) a text study focusing on prominent string musicians’ verbal communication surrounding expressive intonation in performance. Hence, each of the studies investigates a different aspect of the main aim.
The findings of the first study suggest an expertise-related connection between violinists’ intonation preference and meter. The results in the second study indicate that concertmasters’ average leading-tone intonation was sharper than in both equal tempered and just intonations, in performance as well as in their perceptual preferences. In the third study, practising string teachers showed a rich variety of creative teaching strategies to make intonation apprehensible and accessible to children. The fourth study demonstrated how string pedagogues seemed to struggle with their verbal communication regarding intonation practice in expressive performance.
By shedding light on the application of expressive intonation in successful string musicians’ performance, this work discloses parts of musicians’ implicit knowledge concerning their contextually based intonation practice. These new insights may have implications for teaching intonation, inspiring to more efficient communication surrounding expressive performance in instrumental music education.
Publishing year
2025-05-17
Language
English
Publication/Series
Music Education Royal College of Music
Full text
- - 3 MB
Links
Document type
Dissertation
Publisher
Royal College of Music
Topic
- Educational Sciences
- Music
Keywords
- expressivity
- intonation
- leading tone
- melodic intonation
- music perception
- music performance
- pedagogical communication
- pitch
- string instruments
- teaching strategies
- tuning
- violin
Status
Published
ISBN/ISSN/Other
- ISBN: 978-91-88409-44-7
- ISBN: 978-91-88409-45-4
Defence date
17 May 2025
Defence time
13:00
Defence place
Nathan Milsteinsalen, the Royal College of Music in Stockholm, Valhallavägen 105, Stockholm
Opponent
- John M. Geringer (Professor Emeritus of Music)